"Things We Never Got Over" Summary

Introduction

Imagine showing up in a small town with nothing but your car, a phone on the verge of dying, and a heart full of hope—only to discover your life’s about to turn upside down. That’s exactly what happens in Lucy Score’s bestselling romance, “Things We Never Got Over.” This book isn’t just a love story; it’s a heartwarming, laugh-out-loud, and at times heart-wrenching journey about starting over, healing from old wounds, and learning to trust again—even when life keeps throwing you curveballs.

Let’s dive into the world of Knockemout, Virginia, where everyone knows your business, coffee shops are sacred, and the past has a funny way of showing up when you least expect it.

Overview of the Plot

Naomi Witt is a woman on the run—not from the law, but from her old life and a disastrous wedding that never quite happened. She flees to Knockemout, hoping to help her estranged twin sister. Instead of a warm reunion, Naomi is left penniless, carless, and suddenly responsible for an eleven-year-old niece she never knew about.

Enter Knox Morgan, Knockemout’s resident grump and bearded bar owner. He wants nothing to do with Naomi’s drama, but life (and his stubborn sense of duty) have other plans. Together, Naomi and Knox navigate small-town chaos, unexpected family, and the tricky terrain of finding love when you least expect it.

List of Characters

Naomi Witt

• The protagonist, a kind-hearted, fiercely independent woman fleeing her old life.
• Twin sister to Tina, and newly minted guardian to her niece, Waylay.
• Known for her “fixer” personality—she can’t help but help others.

Knox Morgan

• The brooding, beard-sporting owner of Knockemout’s bar.
• Known for his tough exterior and soft spot for the underdog.
• Doesn’t believe in relationships or commitment.

Waylay

• Naomi’s surprise niece, smart, sassy, and struggling to trust adults.
• Caught between childhood and growing up too fast due to her mother’s neglect.

Tina Witt

• Naomi’s troubled, unreliable twin who leaves chaos in her wake.
• Master manipulator, always looking for the next escape.

Nash Morgan

• Knox’s brother, Knockemout’s police chief, dependable and calm.

Liza J

• Sassy, loyal friend to Naomi and the unofficial mayor of the town gossip circuit.

Supporting Cast

• A colorful assortment of townspeople, each with opinions, quirks, and plenty of advice.

Setting: Knockemout, Virginia

Knockemout isn’t just a backdrop—it’s a character in its own right. This small town is:

• Full of charm, gossip, and a sense of community (for better or worse).
• The kind of place where everyone’s business is public knowledge.
• Home to quirky shops, a beloved diner, and a bar that’s the center of social life.

The setting isn’t just window-dressing; it’s the fertile ground where Naomi and Knox’s story grows. The tightly knit community both complicates and enriches their journey, offering as many obstacles as helping hands.

Themes Explored

1. Starting Over

Naomi’s arrival in Knockemout is the ultimate do-over. She’s lost her job, her fiancé, her trust in her sister, and almost everything she owns—except her integrity and sense of humor. The book explores:

• The pain and liberation of letting go of the past.
• The courage it takes to rebuild from scratch.
• How new beginnings can come from the most unexpected disasters.

2. Family—The One You’re Born With and the One You Choose

Family is messy, complicated, and sometimes downright infuriating. Through Naomi, Waylay, and even Knox, the story examines:

• The bonds that tie us to family, even when they hurt us.
• The power of chosen family—friends and community stepping in where blood relatives fail.
• Healing generational wounds and breaking cycles of neglect.

3. Healing, Trust, and Vulnerability

Both Naomi and Knox carry scars—emotional and otherwise. The story gently (and sometimes not-so-gently) uncovers:

• How past trauma shapes our fears and relationships.
• The risk required to open up and truly trust someone.
• The healing power of love, patience, and a well-timed sarcastic remark.

4. Empowerment and Self-Worth

Naomi’s journey from people-pleasing “fixer” to a woman who stands up for herself is central to the book. Readers see:

• The pitfalls of always putting others first.
• The importance of setting boundaries and knowing your own value.
• How self-respect can lead to healthier relationships.

Key Plot Points (No Spoilers)

• Naomi’s Arrival: She lands in Knockemout expecting to save her sister, only to find herself stranded and caretaker to a niece she’s never met.
• Tina’s Disappearance: Tina vanishes, leaving Naomi to pick up the pieces of Waylay’s disrupted life.
• Knox’s Reluctant Help: Knox steps in to help Naomi, despite his vow to avoid “women with problems.”
• New Routines: Naomi tries to build a new life—finding a job, a place to live, and a way to connect with Waylay.
• Small-Town Drama: With Tina’s reputation haunting her, Naomi faces prejudice, gossip, and a series of obstacles.
• Knox and Naomi’s Growing Connection: Sparks fly, but both have reasons to keep their distance.
• Confronting the Past: Both lead characters must face what’s been holding them back—old wounds, fears, and the people they’ve lost.

Emotional Highlights and Relatable Moments

Hitting Rock Bottom—With a Smile

Naomi’s first day in Knockemout isn’t just bad—it’s spectacularly bad. Instead of wallowing, she cracks jokes, faces down the town’s suspicions, and keeps going. Many readers see themselves in her resilience, especially when life feels like one long string of mishaps.

The Unexpected Joy of Found Family

Waylay, prickly and guarded, gradually warms up to Naomi, creating moments that are equal parts heartwarming and hilarious. There’s a scene where their awkward attempts at bonding turn into genuine affection—reminding us that love often shows up in the messiest ways.

The Power of Second Chances

Knox’s gruff exterior hides a man who’s been burned before. Watching him slowly let down his guard is both frustrating and deeply moving. His journey shows that even the most stubborn hearts can change.

Laugh-Out-Loud Small-Town Shenanigans

From nosy neighbors to gossip gone wild, the book is packed with moments that will make you snort coffee out your nose. The town’s well-meaning meddling adds levity and charm, grounding the heavier emotional arcs.

Why Readers Love This Book

• Relatable, flawed characters who feel like old friends.
• Snappy, witty dialogue that keeps the pages turning.
• Authentic depictions of family drama—the kind that makes you laugh and cry at the same time.
• Slow-burn romance with real tension and believable obstacles.
• A strong sense of place—Knockemout feels as real as your own hometown.

Standout Quotes

Here are some lines that capture the spirit of the book (paraphrased to avoid spoilers):

• “Sometimes the things you never get over are the ones that make you who you are.”
• “Finding family isn’t about blood—it’s about who shows up when you need them.”
• “You can’t fix everyone. Sometimes the best you can do is fix yourself.”
• “Love is a risk. But so is never letting anyone close enough to hurt you.”

Practical Takeaways and Insights

While “Things We Never Got Over” is fiction, it offers plenty of real-world wisdom:

What Makes the Romance Special

• Enemies-to-reluctant-allies-to-lovers: Knox and Naomi don’t fall into each other’s arms at first sight. Their connection builds through friction, banter, and shared struggles.
• Mutual growth: Both characters push each other to confront their weaknesses and grow.
• Respect for independence: Their relationship isn’t about “fixing” each other, but about supporting one another’s journeys.
• Authentic chemistry: The romance is full of tension, laughter, and genuine emotional payoff.

How the Book Stands Out in the Genre

Lucy Score’s novel sets itself apart through:

• Layered, believable characters: No one is a caricature; even “villains” have depth.
• Real stakes: The obstacles aren’t contrived; they come from deep-seated emotional wounds and real-life problems.
• A blend of humor and heart: The story balances laugh-out-loud moments with honest, sometimes painful self-discovery.
• Community as a character: The small-town setting isn’t just a backdrop—it’s integral to the plot and character growth.

Reading Experience: What to Expect

Emotions

• Laughter: Prepare for witty comebacks, awkward situations, and the absurdity of small-town life.
• Tears: The characters’ pain and vulnerability are deeply felt.
• Hope: Despite dark moments, the story is ultimately optimistic and uplifting.

Pacing

• Slow-Burn: The romance and emotional healing unfold gradually, giving readers time to invest in the characters.
• Engaging Side Stories: Subplots involving the community, Waylay’s adjustment, and Tina’s shadowy presence keep the story moving.

Accessibility

• Easy to read: Score’s writing is conversational, snappy, and approachable.
• No prior knowledge required: Jump in even if you’re new to romance or small-town fiction.

Who Will Enjoy This Book?

• Fans of contemporary romance looking for more than just fluff.
• Anyone who loves stories about starting over and second chances.
• Readers drawn to quirky towns, rich character development, and found-family themes.
• Those seeking a balance of humor, heartache, and hope.

Table: Major Conflicts and Resolutions (No Spoilers)

Why “Things We Never Got Over” is Worth Your Time

• Relatable Struggles: Naomi’s journey from rock bottom to self-empowerment is a mirror for anyone who’s ever felt stuck or let down.
• Satisfying Romance: The love story is built on mutual respect, healing, and genuine connection—not just attraction.
• Lively Setting: Knockemout is a place you’ll want to visit again and again, thanks to its quirky charm and memorable residents.
• Emotional Payoff: The book delivers laughs, tears, and a strong sense of hope.

Actionable Insights for Your Own Life

• Embrace new beginnings: It’s never too late to start over, no matter how old you are or how messy life gets.
• Set boundaries, even with family: Protecting your peace sometimes means saying “no” to those closest to you.
• Don’t go it alone: Lean on friends, neighbors, and new connections when life gets tough.
• Be kind to yourself: Healing is a journey, and it’s okay to stumble along the way.

Final Thoughts

“Things We Never Got Over” is more than a romance—it’s a story about what it means to rebuild, to trust, and to find joy after heartbreak. Lucy Score’s characters leap off the page, their struggles and triumphs echoing real-life challenges in a way that feels both comforting and inspiring.

Whether you’re here for the slow-burn love story, the quirky small-town antics, or the raw exploration of family and healing, you’ll find plenty to love in Knockemout. So grab a cup of coffee, settle in, and let Naomi and Knox remind you: life’s biggest messes sometimes lead to the most beautiful new beginnings.

Quick Reference: Book Details

Ready for a story that will make you laugh, cry, and believe in second chances? “Things We Never Got Over” is a journey worth taking.