Jessi Kir (2015)
Goodreads Rating
3.98/ 5(12,082 reviews)
Genre
Summary Read
10 min
Book Length
12 Minutes
Sign in to track this book
Ask anything about Things We Know by Heart and get instant answers grounded in the summary.
Quinn Sullivan is dealing with the sudden death of her boyfriend, Trent, in a car accident. Overwhelmed by grief, she struggles with daily life and the emptiness Trent left behind. His family, especially his mother, decides to donate his organs. Quinn believes the heart holds a person's essence, so she finds some comfort in the idea that parts of Trent are still alive. She attends a support group for organ donor families, hoping to connect with recipients. While some recipients respond to letters, the person who received Trent's heart remains anonymous, leaving Quinn feeling incomplete and needing closure.
Quinn believes finding Trent's heart will give her a real connection to him. She begins to quietly look into the organ donation registry. She learns the recipient of Trent's heart is a nineteen-year-old male. Frustrated by the system's privacy rules, Quinn takes matters into her own hands. She uses information from a brief, accidental talk with a hospital employee to narrow down possible candidates. Her search leads her to Colton Thomas, a young man who had a heart transplant around the same time Trent died. Quinn feels a strong need to meet him, believing he has a part of Trent she must find.
Quinn identifies Colton as the likely recipient and plans an "accidental" meeting. She finds him working at a booth at a local fair. She talks to him casually, feeling a complex mix of worry, hope, and an unexpected attraction. Colton does not know their deep connection; he is friendly and engaging. Quinn likes his easygoing nature and the energy he shows, which is very different from her own grief-stricken state. Their first talk is light, but Quinn is very aware of her secret and the heart beating in Colton's chest.
Quinn initially only wanted to find Trent's heart, but she finds herself enjoying Colton's company. They start spending more time together, going on casual dates and sharing stories. Quinn learns Colton loves music and has ambitions; she finds him genuinely kind and interesting. She feels a growing attraction to him, which both excites and confuses her. Their increasing closeness is complicated by her secret; every laugh, every touch, every beat of his heart reminds her of Trent and the ethical problem she faces. She struggles with guilt and the fear of telling the truth.
As Quinn and Colton's relationship grows, Trent's memory remains strong. Quinn constantly compares Colton to Trent, looking for similarities and differences, and wrestling with the idea of moving on. She feels great loyalty to Trent, which conflicts with her growing feelings for Colton. Flashbacks to her time with Trent, their shared dreams, and his sudden death often interrupt her interactions with Colton. This internal struggle causes Quinn significant emotional upset, making it hard for her to fully accept her new feelings without feeling immense guilt and confusion.
Colton, unaware of Quinn's true reasons, tells her about his past struggles with heart disease and his life-saving transplant. He expresses deep thanks for his anonymous donor, acknowledging the gift of a second chance. He shares how the transplant changed his outlook, making him appreciate every moment and pursue his passions with new energy. Quinn listens, her heart aching with the knowledge of who his donor is. Hearing Colton talk about his new heart, his new life, makes the secret even heavier for Quinn, highlighting the great weight of her deception and the pain it could cause.
The burden of knowing Colton has Trent's heart, and keeping it from him, affects Quinn greatly. Her secrecy impacts her interactions with friends and family, who notice her guardedness and emotional changes. She becomes more isolated, unable to confide in anyone about her complicated feelings for Colton and her ethical tightrope walk. The guilt and fear of discovery grow, leading to moments of panic and self-doubt. Quinn realizes her continued deception is unsustainable and causes more pain than it solves, bringing her closer to a breaking point.
As Quinn and Colton become closer, several events threaten to expose Quinn's secret. A talk about scar tissue, a shared memory of Trent's favorite band, or a chance meeting with someone who knew Trent, create moments of intense tension. Quinn becomes increasingly paranoid, always on edge about being found out. These close calls remind her that the truth cannot stay hidden forever. She starts to realize her feelings for Colton are real, and the longer she waits to tell him, the more profound the betrayal will feel, pushing her towards the inevitable talk.
Overwhelmed by guilt and the unsustainable nature of her deception, Quinn decides to tell Colton the truth. In a raw, emotional confession, she reveals that Trent, her deceased boyfriend, was the donor of his heart. Colton is completely shocked and deeply surprised by the news. His first reaction is a mix of disbelief, anger, and deep sadness. The news shatters the foundation of their growing relationship, turning their shared experiences into something tainted by secrecy and manipulation. The revelation is painful for both, forcing them to face the complex and heartbreaking reality of their connection.
After Quinn's confession, Colton needs time and space to process the overwhelming truth. He feels betrayed and questions the authenticity of their connection, struggling with the idea that Quinn sought him out not for who he was, but for the heart inside him. The revelation forces him to re-evaluate everything, including his own identity and his gratitude for the transplant. Quinn, devastated by his reaction, understands his need for distance. Both characters must navigate the emotional fallout, wondering if their bond can survive such a deep and painful truth, or if the secret has permanently broken them apart.
After a period of intense emotional turmoil and separation, Quinn and Colton begin to carefully communicate again. Colton, with time, starts to understand the depth of Quinn's grief and her desperate need to connect with Trent. Quinn, in turn, fully understands the pain and betrayal she caused Colton. They both come to see the complexity of their situation – the tragedy that brought them together, the genuine feelings that developed, and the ethical problem that overshadowed it all. This phase includes difficult conversations, apologies, and a gradual rebuilding of trust, moving towards empathy and mutual understanding.
Through their open and honest discussions, Quinn and Colton reach a new understanding of their relationship. They acknowledge the permanent link created by Trent's heart, but also recognize the genuine connection they formed beyond that initial, complex beginning. They decide to move forward, not denying the past but making it part of their present. Their relationship is unique, with an extraordinary origin story, but it is also built on mutual respect, forgiveness, and a shared appreciation for life. They choose to embrace the future, understanding that love can arise from the most unexpected and challenging circumstances, creating a bond unlike any other.
The Protagonist
Quinn evolves from a grief-stricken girl clinging to the past to someone who learns to embrace a new future, finding love and forgiveness through acknowledging her complex emotions and actions.
The Supporting
Colton goes from unknowingly carrying a profound secret to confronting a painful truth, ultimately choosing understanding and forgiveness to build a new future.
The Supporting
Trent's character provides the initial emotional wound and plot catalyst, his memory gradually shifting from an obstacle to a complex part of Quinn's healing.
The Supporting
They remain consistent sources of support, witnessing Quinn's journey and offering a stable foundation.
The Supporting
Chloe remains a supportive friend, offering perspective and a sense of normalcy, though not fully aware of Quinn's central dilemma.
The Supporting
Her decision for organ donation is a pivotal plot point, establishing the premise for the story.
The novel explores the many sides of grief, especially the intense sorrow after a loved one's sudden death. Quinn's story shows the different stages of grief, from denial and clinging to the past, to the hard process of acceptance and finding new paths to happiness. It examines how people cope with loss, the longing to connect with the deceased, and the challenging, uneven path towards healing and moving forward without forgetting.
“The heart, Quinn had always believed, was the essence of a person. If she found Trent's, then in a way, she would still have a piece of him.”
The story looks at questions of identity, both for Quinn, who struggles to define herself without Trent, and for Colton, whose identity is tied to the gift of a new heart. It explores what connects people: whether it's shared experience, mutual attraction, or even a biological link like an organ transplant. The novel asks what truly connects people and how those connections shape who they become, challenging common ideas of love and relationships.
“He was a stranger, but every beat of his heart was Trent.”
A main theme is the ethical problem Quinn faces by pursuing Colton under false pretenses and keeping her true connection to him a secret. The novel examines the moral complexities of her actions, driven by grief but leading to deception. It explores the consequences of such a secret, the burden it places on the one keeping it, and its deep impact on trust and relationships when revealed. The story makes readers consider the limits of personal need versus the rights and feelings of others.
“How could she explain that the person she was falling for was also the person who held the last physical piece of her first love?”
The novel highlights the idea of second chances, most literally through Colton's heart transplant, which gives him a new opportunity at life. It also applies to Quinn, who, through her complicated relationship with Colton, finds a second chance at love and happiness after great loss. The theme explores the human spirit's resilience and the capacity for hope and growth even after tragedy, suggesting that new beginnings, though often difficult, are possible and can lead to unexpected joys.
“This wasn't just a love story, but one with a ferocious pulse.”
The book explores various forms of love: the intense first love Quinn shared with Trent, the growing and complicated romantic love she develops for Colton, and the more abstract love and gratitude associated with organ donation. It questions whether love can truly replace another, how grief affects new affection, and if an extraordinary circumstance can create a unique and powerful bond. The story suggests that love is not always simple or straightforward, but can be messy, complex, and ultimately transformative.
“She didn’t want to give in to it—especially since he has no idea how they’re connected—but the time Quinn spends with Colton makes her feel alive again.”
The central object driving the protagonist's quest.
Trent's donated heart functions as a psychological MacGuffin. While not a tangible object the characters are physically searching for in the traditional sense, the *idea* and *location* of Trent's heart is the initial driving force behind Quinn's actions. Her belief that the heart holds the essence of Trent compels her to find its recipient, setting the entire plot in motion. It's a symbolic object that represents her desperate need for closure and a piece of her lost love, even as her true motivations evolve.
The audience and Quinn know a crucial secret Colton doesn't.
Dramatic irony is heavily employed throughout the majority of the novel. The reader, along with Quinn, is aware that Colton is the recipient of Trent's heart, while Colton himself remains oblivious to this profound connection. This creates constant tension and suspense, as every interaction between Quinn and Colton is colored by this unspoken truth. The irony highlights Quinn's internal conflict and the precariousness of their developing relationship, making the eventual revelation all the more impactful.
Quinn's past with Trent is revealed through her recollections.
The novel uses Quinn's memories and flashbacks to Trent to provide context for her grief and her deep attachment to him. These snippets of their past relationship serve several purposes: they establish the depth of her love for Trent, explain her desperate need for closure, and highlight the stark contrast between her past happiness and her current sorrow. They also serve as a constant reminder of the secret she's keeping from Colton, influencing her emotional state and decision-making.
The heart represents love, life, essence, and connection.
The heart is the most prominent symbol in the novel, operating on multiple levels. Literally, it is the organ that gives Colton life and was once Trent's. Symbolically, for Quinn, it represents Trent's essence, his soul, and her enduring love for him. Its presence in Colton's chest symbolizes the profound, almost spiritual, connection between the three characters. It signifies life, love, loss, and the complex intertwining of destinies, acting as both a source of pain and a catalyst for new beginnings.
Ready to see how well you understood this book? Take our interactive quiz with 10 questions.
Jessi Kir is a fiction author known for her novel "Things We Know by Heart." Her work often explores themes of love and connection, resonating with readers through relatable characters and emotional depth. Kir's storytelling reflects a contemporary style that engages a diverse audience.
Support the author — grab the full book.
As an Amazon Associate, BookBrief earns from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you. How we're funded.
