Sign in to track this book
Ask anything about Rabble in Arms and get instant answers grounded in the summary.
The story opens with Peter Merrill, a young man from Arundel, Maine, caught up in the American Revolution. He joins Benedict Arnold's expedition to Quebec, a difficult journey through the Maine wilderness. Peter is initially driven by patriotism and a desire for adventure, leaving his family and home behind. The early march is brutal, with starvation, disease, and constant threats of desertion. Peter quickly learns the harsh realities of war and leadership, seeing both the strength and weakness of his fellow soldiers. He bonds with Cap Huff, a seasoned frontiersman, and admires Arnold's determination despite the troops' hardships.
Upon reaching Quebec, the American forces, weakened and exhausted, try to besiege the fortified city. Peter Merrill takes part in the failed assault on December 31, 1775. The attack is a disaster; General Montgomery is killed, and Benedict Arnold is wounded. Peter sees firsthand the British defenses' effectiveness and the severe losses the Americans suffer. He faces the grim reality of combat and random death. Despite the defeat, the remaining Americans, led by Arnold, maintain a loose blockade of Quebec through the winter, enduring extreme cold, smallpox, and dwindling supplies. Peter experiences the demoralizing effect of long inactivity and the constant threat of British attacks.
With British reinforcements arriving in the spring, the American position in Canada becomes impossible to hold. Peter Merrill participates in the long retreat from Quebec, a desperate withdrawal marked by disease, starvation, and constant harassment from pursuing British forces. He sees the complete collapse of the American invasion, as soldiers die from smallpox and dysentery, and morale plummets. The retreat shows a strong will to survive, with Peter and his comrades pushing through immense suffering. During this time, Peter's admiration for Arnold grows as he watches Arnold's relentless efforts to save his men and salvage what he can from the disastrous campaign, often against the incompetence and betrayal of other American officers.
After the retreat from Canada, the story moves to Lake Champlain, the waterway connecting Canada and the American colonies. Peter Merrill is involved in Benedict Arnold's effort to build a fleet of warships from scratch at Skenesborough (now Whitehall, New York) to counter the expected British invasion. This period shows Arnold's resourcefulness and leadership, as he turns raw timber into a fighting navy in months. Peter helps with the construction, learning about naval warfare and the strategic importance of controlling the lake. The urgency of the task is clear, as the Americans know that if the British control Lake Champlain, they will have a clear path to invade New York and potentially divide the colonies.
Peter Merrill participates in the Battle of Valcour Island, a naval engagement on Lake Champlain where Benedict Arnold's hastily built fleet confronts a stronger British force. Despite being outgunned and outnumbered, Arnold uses clever tactics to damage the British and, more importantly, delay their advance. Peter experiences the chaos and terror of naval combat, seeing the bravery of his comrades and the power of cannon fire. Though the American fleet is destroyed, Arnold's actions buy time for the Continental Army to prepare defenses farther south, stopping a British invasion down Lake Champlain in 1776. Peter survives the battle and the subsequent escape of the American remnants.
After the naval campaign, Peter Merrill is at Fort Ticonderoga, a key defensive position. The story then shifts to the deteriorating state of the Northern Department under General Philip Schuyler, and later, General Horatio Gates. Peter observes the political disputes, lack of supplies, and general disarray in the American forces. He witnesses the stunning fall of Fort Ticonderoga to General Burgoyne's advancing British army, a defeat that shocks the American colonies. Peter experiences the despair and confusion among the troops, who are ill-equipped and poorly led. His admiration for Arnold remains, as Arnold is often the most active and capable officer among the general incompetence.
Following Ticonderoga's fall, Peter Merrill is part of the retreating American army trying to slow Burgoyne's advance through upstate New York. He sees General Schuyler's strategic skill in hindering British progress by felling trees, destroying bridges, and creating obstacles. As American forces regroup and grow with militia arrivals, Peter senses a shift in morale. The story highlights the growing tension between General Gates and Benedict Arnold, with Arnold frustrated by Gates's caution and his lack of recognition. Peter observes Arnold's restless energy and his desire to fight the enemy, contrasting sharply with Gates's more passive approach.
Peter Merrill participates in the First Battle of Saratoga, specifically the engagement at Freeman's Farm. He fights under Benedict Arnold, who, despite being nominally under General Gates, takes initiative and leads a fierce attack against the British lines. Peter experiences the brutal, close-quarters fighting, seeing the bravery and determination of the American soldiers. Arnold's aggressive tactics inflict heavy casualties on the British and prevent them from breaking American defenses. However, General Gates, driven by jealousy and a desire for sole credit, fails to reinforce Arnold and later tries to diminish Arnold's role in the victory, leading to a major conflict between the two generals. Peter knows the injustice done to Arnold.
After the First Battle, the conflict between Gates and Arnold grows, ending with Gates relieving Arnold of his command. Peter Merrill observes Arnold's frustration and humiliation. Despite being without an official command, during the Second Battle of Saratoga (Bemis Heights), Arnold, driven by patriotism and military skill, rides onto the battlefield and rallies the American troops at a critical moment. Peter witnesses Arnold's bravery as he leads a decisive charge against the Hessian redoubt, despite being severely wounded in the leg. This heroic act breaks the British lines and secures the American victory, forcing Burgoyne's surrender. Peter sees Arnold's uncredited, but undeniable, role in the triumph.
Immediately after Burgoyne's surrender at Saratoga, Peter Merrill witnesses the elation and relief among the American troops. He reflects on his journey, from the march to Quebec to the decisive victory at Saratoga. The personal cost of the war, and the sacrifices of many individuals, weigh heavily on him. He observes the political maneuvering that deprives Arnold of his credit for the victory, foreshadowing Arnold's later tragic path. Peter, with Cap Huff, looks to the future, understanding that while a major victory has been achieved, the war for independence is far from over. He carries with him the lasting experiences of hardship, courage, and complex heroism.
The Protagonist
Peter transforms from an idealistic youth into a seasoned, pragmatic soldier, deeply loyal to his comrades and appreciative of true leadership, even when unrewarded. He experiences the full spectrum of war's horrors and triumphs.
The Supporting (central figure)
Arnold's arc in the novel showcases his unparalleled military brilliance and self-sacrificing patriotism, which are repeatedly unrewarded and undermined, leading to deep frustration and foreshadowing his later betrayal.
The Supporting
Cap Huff remains a consistent pillar of practical wisdom and loyalty, serving as a grounding force for Peter amidst the chaos of war, his character deepening in his unwavering support for Arnold.
The Supporting
Henry grows from a somewhat naive younger brother into a capable, though still less experienced, soldier under Peter's guidance, mirroring Peter's earlier journey.
The Antagonist
Gates's ambition and jealousy escalate, culminating in his attempts to usurp credit from Arnold at Saratoga, cementing his role as a foil for Arnold's genuine military genius.
The Supporting
Montgomery's brief but impactful arc establishes him as a heroic and self-sacrificing leader, whose death underscores the immense challenges faced by the early American campaigns.
The Supporting
Schuyler's arc demonstrates his strategic acumen in delaying Burgoyne, despite facing political opposition, ultimately contributing to the conditions for the Saratoga victory before being replaced.
The Antagonist
Burgoyne's arc is one of initial confidence leading to a gradual descent into desperation, culminating in his humiliating surrender at Saratoga, a testament to the effectiveness of American resistance.
The novel explores the idea that true heroism often goes unrewarded and unrecognized, contrasting it with the pursuit of glory and political ambition. Benedict Arnold embodies this theme, performing acts of bravery and strategic skill that are repeatedly undermined or credited to others. Peter Merrill, as an observer, learns that heroism is found in perseverance, self-sacrifice, and commitment to a cause, rather than in accolades or public recognition. The theme challenges romanticized notions of war, showing that the most impactful deeds are often done by those who simply do what is necessary, regardless of personal cost.
“For the first time I understood that the glory of battle was a thing of the past, and that the only glory was in keeping alive and doing your duty, however hard it was, and in spite of all the odds.”
Roberts details the human cost of the American Revolution, both physical and psychological. The novel depicts the horrors of starvation, disease (especially smallpox), extreme cold, and the reality of combat. Characters suffer amputations, see comrades die, and endure long periods of despair and demoralization. The story shows that the fight for independence was not a glorious adventure but a struggle marked by suffering and sacrifice, affecting not only soldiers but also civilians through scarcity and displacement. This theme grounds the historical narrative in a human experience.
“We'd learned to live like animals, to sleep in the snow, to eat anything, to fight with anything, and to die without a whimper.”
The novel portrays the contrast between effective and ineffective leadership during the Revolution. Benedict Arnold is a brilliant, decisive, and courageous commander, capable of inspiring his men and achieving the impossible. In contrast, figures like Horatio Gates represent the dangers of ambition, jealousy, and political maneuvering over military competence. The story demonstrates how armies' fates and campaigns' success often depended on their leaders' character and abilities. Poor leadership led to unnecessary suffering and defeat, while inspiring leadership could turn the tide against overwhelming odds. Peter Merrill's experiences highlight the soldier's view of these varied leaders.
“There were men who could lead, and men who could talk, and the talkers often got the credit for what the leaders did.”
Despite the odds, setbacks, and suffering, the American soldiers in the novel show remarkable resilience and perseverance. From the march to Quebec to the retreat from Canada and the battles of Saratoga, the troops, though often dispirited, find the strength to continue fighting for their cause. This theme celebrates the human spirit and the power of collective will in adversity. It shows that the Revolution's ultimate victory was not just a result of strategic skill, but also the stubbornness and determination of ordinary men refusing to give up.
“It seemed impossible that men could suffer so much and still have the will to stand up and fight. But we did.”
Provides an intimate, ground-level perspective of the war.
The story is told through the eyes of Peter Merrill, a young soldier. This first-person perspective allows the reader to experience the war directly and intimately, from the grueling marches and the terror of battle to the daily struggles of hunger and disease. It provides a personal and emotional connection to the historical events, making the grand sweep of the Revolution relatable through the lens of one individual's experiences. Peter's observations and reflections also serve to highlight the character and actions of Benedict Arnold, fostering a deep understanding of Arnold's brilliance and the injustices he faced.
Immersive historical detail grounds the fiction in reality.
Kenneth Roberts was renowned for his meticulous historical research, and this device is central to 'Rabble in Arms.' The novel incorporates extensive details about military tactics, daily life of soldiers, uniforms, weaponry, and the specific geographic and environmental challenges of the campaigns. This rich historical detail creates an immersive and authentic experience, making the reader feel transported to the late 18th century. It lends credibility to the narrative and reinforces the author's intent to portray the American Revolution with as much realism as possible, often correcting popular misconceptions.
Hints at Arnold's future betrayal through his current frustrations.
While the novel concludes before Benedict Arnold's infamous treason, it masterfully employs foreshadowing through Arnold's character arc and the injustices he endures. The repeated instances of his brilliance being unrewarded, his sacrifices unappreciated, and his authority undermined by jealous rivals like Gates, subtly hint at the psychological toll these experiences take on him. The reader is given a profound understanding of the frustration and resentment that could eventually lead such a dedicated patriot down a path of betrayal, making his later actions, though not depicted, more comprehensible within the narrative's context.
Provides guidance, comic relief, and a grounded perspective.
Cap Huff serves as a classic mentor figure to the young protagonist, Peter Merrill. He is an experienced, pragmatic, and often cynical frontiersman who imparts practical wisdom, survival skills, and a dose of reality to Peter. Huff's colorful language and dry humor offer moments of comic relief amidst the grim realities of war. More importantly, he acts as a moral compass and a voice of reason, constantly highlighting the true nature of leadership and the often-unseen sacrifices of ordinary soldiers, reinforcing the themes of heroism and resilience through his unwavering loyalty and clear-sightedness.
Ready to see how well you understood this book? Take our interactive quiz with 10 questions.
Kenneth Roberts was an American author known for his historical novels set in early American history. His notable work, "Rabble in Arms," explores the complexities of the American Revolution through the experiences of its characters. Roberts' fiction often reflects his interest in the historical events and figures of his time.
Support the author — grab the full book.
As an Amazon Associate, BookBrief earns from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you. How we're funded.
