Core Idea
- Difficulty
- Hard
- Read it if
- You are concerned about the state of higher education, the erosion of shared cultural values, or the impact of relativism on intellectual development and democratic citizenship. You appreciate a dense, philosophical critique of modern American society.
- Skip it if
- You are looking for an easy read, are uninterested in critiques of modern liberalism from a conservative philosophical perspective, or are not open to challenging established views on 'openness' and cultural relativism. You dislike lengthy, complex sentences and extensive philosophical discourse.
Key Takeaways from The Closing of the American Mind
The Tyranny of Openness
Uncritical 'openness' has eroded the intellectual and moral foundations of American higher education.
Bloom argues that 'openness,' which once meant critically examining different ideas, has become uncritical relativism in American universities. This modern view suggests all opinions are equally valid, and strong beliefs are intolerant. This intellectual setting, far from encouraging real understanding, creates intellectual laziness and a fear of judgment. This stops students from deeply engaging with philosophical questions or developing a clear moral framework. As a result, a generation cannot tell good arguments from bad, or true ideas from false, leading to intellectual stagnation and moral confusion.
“Openness, itself a product of the West, means the willingness to consider other alternatives, our awareness of the arbitrariness of our own beliefs, and the consequent readiness to replace them with others. It is the virtue that is to lead to the comprehensive perspective.”
In the book: Bloom meticulously traces the historical evolution of 'openness' from its Enlightenment roots, where it was linked to the pursuit of truth, to its contemporary manifestation as a value unto itself, devoid of any substantive content or critical discernment. He points to the pervasive influence of cultural relativism and historicism in the curriculum.
Try this: Actively challenge the assumption that all ideas are equally valid. Engage in rigorous critical analysis of diverse perspectives, seeking to understand their strengths and weaknesses rather than merely accepting their existence. Foster environments where strong, well-reasoned arguments are encouraged, even if they challenge prevailing orthodoxies.
Related ideas: relativism, nihilism, moral-decay
The Lost Canon
The abandonment of classical Western texts has deprived students of a shared intellectual heritage and the tools for self-discovery.
Bloom regrets the decline of the Great Books curriculum. He argues that discarding the foundational texts of Western thought — Plato, Aristotle, Shakespeare, Locke, Rousseau — leaves students intellectually poor. These works, he believes, are not just old artifacts but ongoing conversations about human questions of justice, virtue, meaning, and a good life. By engaging with these thinkers, students gain cultural literacy and develop critical thinking, moral reasoning, and self-reflection. Without this shared intellectual ground, education becomes fragmented, lacking coherence and depth. Students are left without guidance for complex ethical and existential problems.
“There is one thing a professor can be absolutely certain of: almost every student entering the university believes, or says he believes, that truth is relative.”
In the book: Bloom contrasts the intellectual rigor of earlier university curricula, which emphasized the study of classical texts, with the fragmented and often 'relevant' course offerings of his time. He cites the lack of familiarity among students with foundational philosophical concepts.
Try this: Advocate for and engage with core curricula that include foundational texts in philosophy, literature, and political thought. Encourage deep reading and discussion of these works, focusing on their enduring questions rather than merely their historical context. Seek out opportunities for interdisciplinary study.
Related ideas: great-books, western-canon, classical-education
The Soul of the Student
Modern education fails to cultivate the soul, leaving students without a sense of purpose or a coherent moral identity.
Bloom believes that modern education, focused on job training or superficial 'relevance,' ignores higher learning's main task: shaping the student's inner life. He argues that true education should be a journey of self-discovery, pushing students to face fundamental questions about human nature, morality, and life's meaning. Instead, students often get a fragmented curriculum that offers little help in developing a coherent worldview or a strong moral compass. This neglect leaves them vulnerable to fleeting trends, unable to form deep connections, and ultimately empty, lacking the inner resources for a fulfilling life and responsible citizenship. The university, once a place for profound self-cultivation, has become a market for skills and opinions.
“The students are not interested in the permanent questions, because they are not interested in themselves.”
In the book: Bloom observes a pervasive apathy among students towards serious philosophical inquiry, often preferring immediate gratification or practical skills over the arduous pursuit of wisdom. He notes their difficulty in discussing profound moral issues without resorting to relativistic clichés.
Try this: Prioritize education that encourages deep introspection and ethical reasoning. Engage with philosophy, literature, and art that challenge personal assumptions and provoke contemplation on fundamental human questions. Seek mentors who can guide this process of self-formation.
Related ideas: self-knowledge, moral-philosophy, character-formation
Rock and the Retreat from Eros
Rock music, as a cultural force, dulls the soul's capacity for higher aspirations and genuine love.
Bloom argues that rock music, far from being harmless entertainment, strongly harms young people. He sees it as a raw expression of sexual energy that bypasses reason and creates a frantic, often violent, emotional state. This constant input of immediate gratification and sensual stimulation, he contends, dulls the capacity for more refined pleasures, deep thought, and genuine romantic love (Eros). By reducing human connection to a primal urge, rock music hinders the development of nuanced emotions and intellectual curiosity needed to pursue truth and beauty. This ultimately contributes to the spiritual decline of the youth.
“Rock music has one appeal only, a barbaric appeal, to primitive orgiastic rhythms and sexual frenzy. There is no sentiment, only sentimentality. There is no love, only the itch.”
In the book: Bloom dedicates a significant portion to analyzing the cultural impact of rock music, contrasting its effects with the more elevating and inspiring music of previous generations. He describes its hypnotic rhythms and explicit lyrics as undermining the development of a refined inner life.
Try this: Cultivate an appreciation for diverse forms of music and art, including classical and other genres that provoke intellectual and emotional depth. Be mindful of the emotional and intellectual impact of media consumption. Seek out art that inspires contemplation and elevates the spirit.
Related ideas: cultural-critique, eros, aesthetic-education
The German Connection: From Weimar to America
The intellectual currents that undermined Weimar Germany found an echo in American academia, leading to similar dangers.
Bloom draws a controversial parallel between Weimar Germany's intellectual climate and contemporary American universities. He argues that the unquestioning acceptance of German philosophical ideas like historicism and relativism, especially as simplified by figures like Nietzsche and Heidegger, contributed to the erosion of shared values and rational foundations in both places. While these philosophers offered insights, their reception in America, Bloom suggests, often removed their complexities, leaving a destructive relativism that denied objective truth and morality. This intellectual history, he warns, risks leading America down a similar path of cultural fragmentation and a loss of faith in reason, similar to the conditions before political extremism in Germany.
“Nietzsche was the last great philosopher to speak to us directly about the possibility of human greatness and the challenge of nihilism.”
In the book: Bloom traces the influence of German philosophy, particularly Nietzsche and Heidegger, on American intellectual thought, highlighting how their ideas were often misinterpreted or selectively applied to justify radical relativism within academia. He references the 'crisis of values' debates.
Try this: Engage critically with complex philosophical ideas, understanding their historical context and potential misinterpretations. Avoid simplistic reductions of profound thinkers. Study history to understand the consequences of intellectual movements on political and social structures.
Related ideas: historicism, nihilism, weimar-republic
Feminism's Unintended Consequences
While well-intentioned, certain aspects of feminism have inadvertently contributed to the confusion surrounding male-female relations and the erosion of natural distinctions.
Bloom critically examines modern feminism, arguing that its pursuit of absolute equality, especially making men and women 'interchangeable,' has had negative consequences. He contends that by denying or downplaying inherent, complementary differences between the sexes, feminism has confused gender roles, undermined traditional family structures, and, most importantly, suppressed 'Eros' — the natural, spiritual, and intellectual attraction between men and women that forms deep relationships and procreation. This suppression, he suggests, leaves individuals isolated and unable to form meaningful bonds, contributing to a broader societal unease and a loss of purpose, rather than true liberation.
“The feminists' project, in its present form, is the attempt to make men and women indistinguishable in all functions and relations, and this has led to a suppression of eros.”
In the book: Bloom analyzes the rhetoric of feminist movements, particularly their emphasis on dismantling all traditional gender roles and distinctions. He observes the resulting confusion in male-female relationships and the decline in courtship and family formation among young people.
Try this: Engage in nuanced discussions about gender, acknowledging both equality of opportunity and potential complementary differences. Seek to understand and foster healthy, meaningful relationships that embrace complexity rather than seeking to erase all distinctions. Reflect on the broader societal impact of gender ideologies.
Related ideas: gender-roles, eros, social-engineering
The Poverty of Philanthropy
Large philanthropic foundations, often driven by progressive ideals, inadvertently undermine true intellectual inquiry.
Bloom critiques the role of large philanthropic foundations in shaping academic discussion. He argues that their well-intentioned efforts often lead to intellectual conformity instead of real innovation. He suggests that by funding specific research, departments, and 'relevant' studies — especially those aligned with progressive social goals — these foundations inadvertently steer universities away from fundamental, timeless questions and towards fashionable, often temporary, concerns. This funding, he argues, creates a dependency that stifles independent thought, rewards intellectual fads, and discourages scholars from pursuing unpopular but potentially important inquiries. This contributes to the university's intellectual decline rather than its growth.
“The foundations have joined the universities in the business of 'social engineering,' and they have done so with a vengeance.”
In the book: Bloom points to the significant influence of major foundations in establishing new academic fields, funding specific research, and shaping university priorities, often with an emphasis on 'social relevance' over pure inquiry. He implies a top-down control over intellectual direction.
Try this: Support intellectual institutions that prioritize independent inquiry and the pursuit of truth over ideological conformity or immediate social utility. Be critical of funding streams that appear to dictate research outcomes. Foster environments where diverse intellectual approaches are genuinely valued.
Related ideas: academic-freedom, intellectual-conformity, higher-education-funding
The Crisis of the American Regime
The intellectual crisis in universities directly threatens the principles and stability of American liberal democracy.
Bloom's main concern is not just education but the future of American democracy. He argues that citizens educated in relativism, without a shared moral compass, and unable to reason critically, cannot sustain a republic built on natural rights, reasoned debate, and civic virtue. When all values are equally valid, and objective truth is dismissed, the basis for intelligent self-governance weakens. The university, once meant to cultivate responsible citizens who could discern truth and act virtuously, now produces individuals ill-equipped to defend or understand their political system's philosophical basis. This leaves the 'American mind' vulnerable to demagoguery and intellectual stagnation.
“The crisis of the university is the crisis of Western man.”
In the book: Bloom links the decline in philosophical education and the rise of relativism to a weakening of civic understanding and engagement. He expresses concern over the inability of students to articulate or defend the principles of the American founding documents.
Try this: Actively engage in civic life and defend the principles of liberal democracy through informed discourse and critical thinking. Support educational reforms that prioritize civic education and the study of foundational political philosophy. Understand the connection between intellectual health and political stability.
Related ideas: liberal-democracy, civic-virtue, political-philosophy
The Search for Meaning: Beyond the Cave
True education should liberate students from the 'cave' of contemporary prejudices to seek enduring truths.
At its heart, Bloom's work calls for a return to the Socratic ideal of education, which he frames through Plato's Allegory of the Cave. He believes education's purpose is to free students from conventional wisdom, temporary opinions, and unexamined beliefs — the 'cave' of their culture — and guide them towards enduring truth and self-knowledge. This journey, though hard, is essential for human flourishing and developing truly free and virtuous individuals. He regrets that modern universities, instead of leading students out of the cave, often reinforce their prejudices or trap them in a new, more complex darkness by denying the existence of a 'light' or objective truth to be sought.
“Education is the movement from darkness to light.”
In the book: Bloom frequently references Plato's Allegory of the Cave as a metaphor for the educational journey. He contrasts the 'enlightenment' offered by classical education with the 'darkness' of uncritical relativism prevalent in modern academia.
Try this: Embrace intellectual curiosity and a lifelong commitment to seeking truth, even if it challenges comfortable beliefs. Engage in philosophical inquiry and critical self-reflection. Be skeptical of prevailing orthodoxies and popular opinions, and actively seek deeper understanding.
Related ideas: plato, socratic-method, truth-seeking
The Peril of Value-Neutrality
The university's attempt to be 'value-neutral' is a self-defeating illusion that ultimately promotes a specific, corrosive ideology.
Bloom critiques the idea that universities can or should be 'value-neutral.' He argues that this concept is a dangerous illusion, as claiming neutrality often hides a set of values, typically those of radical relativism and an uncritical acceptance of all cultural forms. By refusing to judge the worth of ideas, cultures, or moral frameworks, the university implicitly teaches that such judgments are impossible or illegitimate. This, he contends, is not neutrality but a specific ideological stance that undermines education's purpose — which is to discern, evaluate, and pursue the good, the true, and the beautiful. The result is an intellectual environment where conviction is suspect and serious moral inquiry is stifled.
“The university has become a place where all opinions are treated equally, and none are taken seriously.”
In the book: Bloom observes the institutional policies and pedagogical approaches within universities that promote a 'hands-off' approach to moral and cultural evaluation, often under the guise of inclusivity. He highlights the fear of appearing 'judgmental' as a barrier to serious ethical discourse.
Try this: Recognize that true education involves making reasoned judgments and evaluations. Challenge claims of absolute value-neutrality, and critically examine the underlying assumptions of any educational approach. Engage in robust, respectful debate about moral and intellectual values.
Related ideas: moral-relativism, postmodernism, academic-ideology
The Closing of the American Mind Quotes
“The students are undirected and their souls are empty, leaving them open to whatever the university or the media offers.”
“Openness and the relativism that accompanies it are the great insight of our times.”
“There is one thing a professor can be absolutely certain of: almost every student entering the university believes, or says he believes, that truth is relative.”
“The most successful tyranny is not the one that uses force to achieve conformity but the one that makes conformity sound like a good idea.”
“Education is the movement from darkness to light.”
“Parents have lost their authority, and with it, their ability to transmit values to their children.”
“Rock music has one appeal only, a savage appeal, to the most universal and primitive part of the soul, sexual desire.”
“The university now offers a smorgasbord of courses, none of which are meant to lead to wisdom, but rather to a career.”
“The real danger is not that we will become Nazis or Communists, but that we will become a nation of nullities.”
“Liberal education is the cultivation of the soul, not the training of a professional.”
“The study of history is a cure for provincialism.”
“Every solution of a problem is a new problem.”
“Genuine education is not a process of filling a bucket but of igniting a fire.”
“The United States is a land of immigrants, but it is also a land of shared principles.”
“Without the great books, we are like men in a cave, seeing only shadows and mistaking them for reality.”
Quiz
10 questions on the main ideas. Each answer comes with a short explanation.
Question 1
According to Allan Bloom, what is the fundamental nature of the crisis facing 20th-century America?
- Primarily an economic crisis due to global competition.
- Essentially an intellectual crisis stemming from a decline in serious thought.
- A moral crisis caused by the weakening of religious institutions.
- A political crisis resulting from partisan gridlock.
Show answer
B. Essentially an intellectual crisis stemming from a decline in serious thought. Bloom explicitly argues that the social/political crisis of 20th-century America is 'really an intellectual crisis,' emphasizing the decay of serious intellectual engagement as the root problem.
Question 2
What does Bloom identify as a major consequence of the decline of the liberal arts curriculum in universities?
- Increased specialization leading to greater scientific innovation.
- Students becoming more adaptable to diverse career paths.
- A lack of shared intellectual ground and a coherent understanding of the Western tradition.
- Greater emphasis on vocational training and practical skills.
Show answer
C. A lack of shared intellectual ground and a coherent understanding of the Western tradition. Bloom laments the loss of a common intellectual framework, particularly the decline of the Great Books, which he believes prevented students from engaging with foundational questions and understanding their place in the Western tradition.
Question 3
Which philosopher's ideas, particularly regarding the 'revaluation of all values,' does Bloom heavily critique for their influence on modern thought and the erosion of traditional moral frameworks?
- John Locke
- Jean-Jacques Rousseau
- Friedrich Nietzsche
- Immanuel Kant
Show answer
C. Friedrich Nietzsche Bloom dedicates significant attention to Nietzsche's influence, particularly how his radical critique of truth and morality contributed to the relativism and nihilism Bloom saw pervading American intellectual life.
Question 4
What does Bloom mean by the 'closing of the American mind'?
- A literal decrease in literacy rates among the general population.
- A growing intellectual dogmatism and an unwillingness to seriously consider different viewpoints.
- The increasing privatization of education, making it inaccessible to many.
- The decline of American influence in global intellectual discourse.
Show answer
B. A growing intellectual dogmatism and an unwillingness to seriously consider different viewpoints. The 'closing' refers not to ignorance, but to a false openness that embraces relativism, making students unwilling to critically engage with or truly believe in the possibility of objective truth, thus closing their minds to genuine philosophical inquiry.
Question 5
Bloom argues that the popular embrace of 'openness' has ironically led to what outcome in American society?
- A more tolerant and understanding populace.
- Greater intellectual curiosity and a desire for diverse knowledge.
- A pervasive relativism that undermines the search for truth and moral foundations.
- Increased political participation and civic engagement.
Show answer
C. A pervasive relativism that undermines the search for truth and moral foundations. Bloom contends that 'openness,' when understood as the belief that all opinions are equally valid, leads to relativism, making it impossible to genuinely judge or prefer one way of life or set of ideas over another, thereby hindering true intellectual pursuit.
Question 6
What role does music, particularly rock music, play in Bloom's critique of contemporary American culture?
- He sees it as a healthy expression of youthful rebellion and creativity.
- He views it as a significant corrupting force that excites passions and dulls the intellect, hindering rational thought.
- He believes it fosters a sense of community and shared cultural identity.
- He largely ignores it, focusing instead on academic texts.
Show answer
B. He views it as a significant corrupting force that excites passions and dulls the intellect, hindering rational thought. Bloom famously dedicates a chapter to the deleterious effects of rock music, arguing that its sensual appeal overwhelms the capacity for rational thought and fosters emotional instability, thus undermining serious intellectual and moral development.
Question 7
Bloom suggests that the university's abandonment of its role as a guardian of 'high culture' and timeless truths has led to what primary outcome?
- Universities becoming more responsive to student demands.
- A greater emphasis on vocational training and job preparedness.
- Students lacking a coherent understanding of purpose and a framework for moral judgment.
- Increased funding for scientific research.
Show answer
C. Students lacking a coherent understanding of purpose and a framework for moral judgment. By abandoning its role in transmitting a shared cultural heritage and fostering philosophical inquiry into fundamental questions, universities leave students without a grounding in timeless truths, leading to confusion about meaning and morality.
Question 8
Which of the following best describes Bloom's view on the American founding principles, particularly as expressed in the Declaration of Independence?
- He sees them as inherently flawed and requiring complete overhaul.
- He views them as based on sound philosophical reasoning, particularly Lockean natural rights, but notes their subsequent erosion.
- He believes they were too idealistic and impractical for real-world governance.
- He argues they were primarily economic in nature, not philosophical.
Show answer
B. He views them as based on sound philosophical reasoning, particularly Lockean natural rights, but notes their subsequent erosion. Bloom respects the philosophical underpinnings of the American founding, particularly its reliance on natural rights theory (drawing from Locke), seeing it as a rational and principled basis for government, whose ideals have been subsequently undermined.
Question 9
What does Bloom suggest as a potential remedy for the intellectual crisis he describes?
- Increased government funding for public education.
- A return to the serious study of classic texts and philosophical inquiry in universities.
- Implementing more diverse and multicultural curricula.
- Encouraging students to engage more with contemporary popular culture.
Show answer
B. A return to the serious study of classic texts and philosophical inquiry in universities. Bloom consistently advocates for a return to the study of the 'Great Books' and a rigorous engagement with perennial philosophical questions as the path to cultivating truly open and inquiring minds.
Question 10
Bloom argues that the modern university's emphasis on 'value-free' social science research ultimately leads to what problem for students?
- A deeper understanding of societal complexities.
- An inability to make moral judgments or distinguish between better and worse ways of life.
- Greater objectivity in their personal beliefs.
- Improved critical thinking skills in scientific fields.
Show answer
B. An inability to make moral judgments or distinguish between better and worse ways of life. By eschewing value judgments in the name of objectivity, social science, as Bloom critiques it, deprives students of the tools and confidence to assess the moral worth of different cultures, political systems, or individual choices, fostering a debilitating relativism.
The Closing of the American Mind FAQ
What is 'The Closing of the American Mind' about?
Allan Bloom's 'The Closing of the American Mind' argues that the social and political crises in 20th-century America stem from an intellectual crisis, particularly within higher education. He critiques the decline of liberal education and the embrace of relativism, which he believes has eroded students' ability to engage with profound ideas and pursue truth.
Does Bloom's critique of higher education still apply today?
Many readers and scholars find Bloom's criticisms of relativism, the decline of the canon, and the focus on specialized vocational training in universities to be highly relevant in contemporary discussions about higher education. While the specific cultural context has evolved, the underlying concerns about intellectual rigor and moral clarity persist.
What is the concept of 'relativism' as discussed by Allan Bloom?
For Bloom, relativism is the belief that all values, truths, and moral systems are equally valid and subjective, with no objective standard to judge them. He argues that this pervasive ideology, particularly within universities, prevents students from seriously grappling with fundamental philosophical questions and from developing a coherent understanding of good and evil.
How does 'The Closing of the American Mind' differ from other critiques of education?
'The Closing of the American Mind' stands out through its deep philosophical and historical analysis, tracing the roots of America's intellectual crisis back to Enlightenment thinkers and German philosophy. Unlike many contemporary critiques that focus on practical reforms, Bloom's work is a profound lament for the loss of a particular intellectual tradition and the pursuit of objective truth.
Who was Allan Bloom and what was his philosophical background?
Allan Bloom (1930-1992) was an American philosopher, classicist, and political theorist, best known for his work on Plato and Rousseau. A student of Leo Strauss, Bloom was a fierce advocate for liberal education rooted in the study of classic texts and the pursuit of timeless philosophical questions, believing these were essential for a healthy democracy.
What does Bloom mean by 'the American mind'?
By 'the American mind,' Bloom refers to the collective intellectual and moral disposition of American society, particularly as shaped by its educational institutions and cultural trends. He argues that this mind has become 'closed' to serious philosophical inquiry and the pursuit of objective truth, instead embracing a complacent relativism.
Does 'The Closing of the American Mind' offer solutions to the intellectual crisis?
While primarily diagnostic, Bloom's book implicitly advocates for a return to a more traditional liberal education, emphasizing the study of canonical Western texts and a serious engagement with fundamental philosophical questions. He suggests that fostering genuine intellectual curiosity and the pursuit of truth are crucial for revitalizing the American mind.
What impact did 'The Closing of the American Mind' have upon its release?
Published in 1987, the book became an unexpected bestseller, sparking widespread public and academic debate about the state of American education and culture. It was both praised for its incisive critique and criticized for its conservative stance and perceived elitism, solidifying Bloom's status as a significant cultural commentator.
Similar books
- Orthodoxy
G.K. Chesterton
4.2 (31k) average on GoodreadsSpiritualityDefends traditional wisdom and reason against modern intellectual fads, sharing Bloom's skepticism of uncritical 'progress'.
- 1984
George Orwell
4.2 (3.1M) average on GoodreadsPoliticsIn a future where surveillance and thought control are absolute, a man's search for truth clashes with the Party, showing that hope can be a form of rebellion.
- Animal Farm
George Orwell
4.0 (2.7M) average on GoodreadsPoliticsA farm animals' rebellion against humans turns into a pig-led dictatorship, showing how power corrupts and revolutionary ideals are betrayed.
- Freakonomics: A Rogue Economist Explores the Hidden Side of Everything
Steven D. Levitt
4.0 (709k) average on GoodreadsBusinessThis book uses economic principles to reveal the surprising incentives behind everything from drug dealing and real estate to cheating teachers and the decline of crime.
- I Am Malala: The Story of the Girl Who Stood Up for Education and Was Shot by the Taliban
Malala Yousafzai
4.1 (419k) average on GoodreadsPoliticsA teenage girl from a Taliban-controlled valley refuses to give up her books, becoming a global voice for education even after an assassination attempt.
- Atlas Shrugged
Ayn Rand
3.7 (354k) average on GoodreadsPoliticsIn a dystopian America where innovators vanish, a brilliant heiress races to uncover the truth behind the disappearing industrialists and the enigmatic John Galt, who vows to stop the world's progress.
Enjoyed the summary?
A summary gives you the shape of the book. The book itself has the detail, the examples and the voice.
Find The Closing of the American Mind on AmazonAs an Amazon Associate, BookBrief earns from qualifying purchases. How we're funded







